Old School New York Pizza logo facebook-icon star2 star

You're invited, or enjoy at home

All of our vegetables are purchased fresh daily

  • Dine in

  • Carry out  

  • Coming Soon Beer & Wine

  • 15 styles of pizza

  • 18" pies or by the slice

  • Calzones

  • Gelato

Contact Us Today Check out our Menu

ALL DAY, EVERYDAY

Two slices of Pizza with a Fountain Drink

$6 Special  

Back East, every neighborhood has its pizza shop where generations of locals go. They know the guys behind the counter and tell them about their day. In Louisville, we're that place.  

Contact us today

$2.00 discount  

on any pie with veteran ID

(not valid with any other coupon)  

Let Us Cater Your Next Event!  

Real pizza, just like in Brooklyn

VETERAN OWNED

AND

OPERATED

OLD SCHOOL N.Y. PIZZA

SUPPORTS

THE DISABLED

AMERICAN

VETERANS..

PLEASE DO THE SAME

banner2

That’s it!... We’ve done our best to keep things simple around here. Easier for you… easier for us. All our pies are the same size… 18”, 8 slices a pie one pie will feed three to four people.

shutterstock_61881940

•Children and adults welcome to participate

•Trick or treating from 4pm–8pm

•Gelato free for all attending

Announcing costume winners at 8pm:

1st place receives a $50 gift certificate

2nd place receives $25 gift certificate

3rd place receives any 1 pizza of your choice

Halloween costume contest

Tuesday October 28th

banner2

Sunday Football Special   

Buy a pizza at a regular price, get second pizza with equal or less value for half price.

Monday Night

Football Special

$5 off in any purchase of $20 or more.

New York Pizza

Comes to Kentucky

Old School NY Pizza will be delivering on Halloween. Within a 3 mile radius from the store only.